Skip to main content

Does Consciousness Serve a Purpose? An Interview with Prof. Roger Walsh by 'Closer to Truth'

Professor Roger Walsh* delves into the nature and purpose of human consciousness. He believes it is essential to approach the question of consciousness from multiple perspectives including evolutionary theory, biology, neuroscience, cultural studies, and spiritual studies. Each discipline provides a unique insight into consciousness.

Evolutionary theorists are divided: some view consciousness as an accidental byproduct, while others see it as essential for survival, a sophisticated means through which DNA replicates.

Neuroscientists generally posit that consciousness arises from the brain's processes.

Those in cultural studies argue that our consciousness is largely shaped by the culture we grow up in.

From a spiritual or contemplative perspective, it's believed that the primary state of human consciousness is somewhat clouded. Therefore, one of the primary tasks of consciousness might be to refine and understand itself better. The meditative traditions provide methods for this, emphasizing the cultivation of awareness, clarity, and positive emotions like love and compassion. They view enlightenment or the awakening of consciousness to its true nature as the ultimate goal.

Scientifically, while certain aspects of consciousness can be studied, like the neurophysiology of those in enlightened states, there are limitations to our understanding. The contemplative traditions suggest that individuals can use their minds as laboratories to personally investigate the claims made about consciousness. Professor Walsh acknowledges the tension between the desire for a definitive answer about the ultimate purpose of consciousness and the recognition of science's limitations in providing that answer.

*Pr. Roger Walsh is an Australian professor of Psychiatry, Philosophy and Anthropology at the University of California, Irvine, in the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, within UCI's College of Medicine




See the interview on YouTube channel of "Closer to Truth"

Popular posts from this blog

Carl Sagan on (why we should save kids from) central government's educational system

“…my experience, my experience is… you go, talk to kindergarten kids or first grade kids… you find a class full of science enthusiasts and they ask deep questions… What is a dream? Why do we have toes? Why is the moon round? What's the birthday of the world? Why is grass green?... These are profound important questions they just bubble right out of them... You go and talk to 12th grade students and there's none of that, they've become leaden and incurious… Something terrible has happened between kindergarten and 12th grade and that's not just puberty…”

Drawing the Line: The Life, Ink, and Cheeky Revelations of late Joe Matt's 'Peepshow

Joe Matt, the trailblazing American cartoonist renowned for his series "Peepshow," died of a heart attack on September 18, 2023, while channeling his life onto paper at his drawing desk. More than just a series of doodles, "Peepshow" was a diary in ink that delved into the dark recesses of Matt's psyche—addressing taboo topics like pornography and masturbation, while artfully exploring the complexities of mental health and sexuality. In "Peepshow," Matt offered a masterclass in vulnerability, serving up raw introspections and existential conundrums that made readers both squirm and resonate. And he did it all with an artistic panache characterised by meticulous lines, vivacious characters, and innovative panel layouts that would've made even the most prudish reader take a second glance. But Matt's work was more than self-absorbed  introspection—it was a sociocultural critique wrapped in comic form. Born from the cultural currents of the 1980s a...

Lexical Lunacy: The Enigmatic Minds Behind the Oxford English Dictionary

In "The Dictionary People: The Unsung Heroes Who Created the Oxford English Dictionary", author Sarah Ogilvie found “an above average number of ‘lunatics’” among the Dictionary People. “Was it their madness that drove them to do so much Dictionary work, or was it the Dictionary work that drove them mad?” In the Oxford English Dictionary, a "Dr WC Minor"is referred to as a contributor only to be discovered later that, while he was an American surgeon, he was also a paranoid schizophrenic probable sex addict who had been committed to Broadmoor Criminal Lunatic Asylum after shooting a man dead. Another subeditor and reader, John Dormer – who seems from his quotations (“humbug”, “minx”, “hanky panky”) to have been rather fun – was admitted to Croydon Mental Hospital aged 35 in 1907, hearing voices. Eustace Frederick Bright, who started contributing as an 18-year-old medical student, was addicted to cocaine and morphine, and died of an overdose, aged 29, on the toilet fl...